The working sequence.
7 sectionsFollow the document’s sequence, or jump to the step you need.
- 01Part 1: Minimum Viable Foundation Checklist
- 02Part 2: Scaling Readiness Score
- 03Part 2: Calculate Your Total
| Status | Criteria |
|---|---|
| PASS | Matched-event values within 5% under documented definitions |
| FAIL | Checked matched-event discrepancy exceeds 5%; unavailable data stays Not checked |
Source: View the complete rubric · Source-defined bands. Your account has not been scored.
Jump to a section
Put this guide to work
Review must-pass prerequisites and a scaling-readiness rubric, then assign foundation work.
Your task: Review scaling prerequisites. Record the source, date range and reviewer beside the result. Leave anything you have not checked marked Not checked.
How to interpret it: Use the rubric to assign foundation work. Passing a checklist does not establish profitable scaling or authorize a budget increase.
Related work: The F.S.S. Protocol for Google Ads Scaling · Find the next account fix across 15 checks.
Part 1: Minimum Viable Foundation Checklist
This is an operator review framework. Numeric, count and architecture thresholds below are worksheet preferences, not universal platform prerequisites. Review applicability, severity and evidence before deciding what blocks a budget change. Mark unchecked items Not checked; exclude N/A from earned and possible points. Use fixed 9-item/100-point bands only with complete applicable coverage.
1. Conversion Tracking Accuracy
Worksheet target: Matched-event values within 5% over a documented sample/window; do not compare all Ads-attributed revenue with all OMS revenue.
How to check: Reconcile a matched-order/event sample using compatible currency, timestamps, attribution and tax/refund definitions. Ads-attributed revenue and total OMS revenue are different populations and need not match. Apply the percentage bands only to matched-event value accuracy; missing comparison data remains Not checked.
Why it matters: If your conversion values are off by more than 5%, Google's Smart Bidding is optimizing toward wrong numbers. A 15% overcount means the algorithm thinks campaigns are more profitable than they are. It will spend more aggressively on traffic that does not actually convert at the reported rate.
| Status | Criteria |
|---|---|
| PASS | Matched-event values within 5% under documented definitions |
| FAIL | Checked matched-event discrepancy exceeds 5%; unavailable data stays Not checked |
2. Single Conversion Action
Threshold: Intended primary outcomes mapped correctly, with no duplicate credit for the same purchase. Multiple distinct outcomes may be intentional.
How to check: Review selected campaign goals, primary actions, counting and transaction deduplication. Distinguish legitimate distinct outcomes from two actions recording the same purchase.
| Status | Criteria |
|---|---|
| PASS | Intended primary outcomes and values verified without duplicate purchase credit |
| FAIL | Verified wrong outcome, missing intended purchase measurement or duplicate purchase credit |
3. Enhanced Conversions Verified
Threshold: Applicable, permitted enhanced-conversion data flow verified using the actual implementation diagnostics; otherwise mark N/A or Not checked.
How to check: Confirm applicability and customer-data policies, then inspect the actual tag/API implementation diagnostics. Tag Assistant can support a tag test; a toggle is not proof of successful matching.
Why it matters: Verify permitted customer-data handling and actual diagnostics for the implementation; enabling a toggle establishes neither data flow nor a recovery percentage.
| Status | Criteria |
|---|---|
| PASS | Applicable permitted data flow and implementation diagnostics verified |
| FAIL | Verified fault in an applicable permitted implementation; unavailable evidence stays Not checked |
4. Merchant Center Clean
Threshold: Zero active Critical disapprovals in Google Merchant Center.
How to check: Go to Merchant Center > Diagnostics. Filter to "Critical" issues. You should see zero.
Why it matters: Critical disapprovals mean products are not showing in Shopping results at all. You are paying for campaign infrastructure that cannot serve ads on those products. Review stated account-level and product-level issues rather than inferring penalties on unaffected products.
| Status | Criteria |
|---|---|
| PASS | Zero critical disapprovals |
| FAIL | Any active critical disapprovals |
5. Customer List Uploaded
Threshold: Applicable customer-list use is permitted and current serving eligibility is verified; no universal 1,000-entry prerequisite for every account.
How to check: Inspect permitted first-party collection, current Customer Match eligibility, list freshness and actual active-user eligibility for the intended network. Upload count and active eligible users differ; use N/A where list use is not appropriate.
Why it matters: Customer lists give Google first-party signal to learn from. In Performance Max, these lists directly influence audience signals. In Smart Bidding, they help the algorithm identify patterns in who actually buys. A list is one possible input; absence alone does not establish that every campaign starts without useful signals.
| Status | Criteria |
|---|---|
| PASS | Applicable list use is permitted, relevant and meets verified serving eligibility |
| FAIL | Verified eligibility, permission, freshness or intended-use fault; N/A is excluded |
6. Campaign Separation
Threshold: Branded and prospecting traffic running in separate campaigns.
How to check: Look at your campaign list. Branded search should be in its own campaign. Prospecting search should be separate. Shopping or Performance Max for branded queries should be separate from prospecting Shopping/Performance Max.
Why it matters: Separate reporting of existing brand interest and acquisition helps interpret outcomes. Neither this four-pocket architecture nor particular conversion rates apply universally.
| Status | Criteria |
|---|---|
| PASS | Branded and prospecting clearly separated at the campaign level |
| FAIL | Branded and prospecting mixed in the same campaign |
7. Brand Negatives Applied
Threshold: Supported brand-query controls and observed coverage match each campaign’s intended role; excluding every brand variation is not universally required.
How to check: Go to each prospecting campaign > Negative Keywords. Search for your brand name. Check common misspellings, abbreviations, and variations. Review the intended exclusions and observed query coverage; some brand demand may be intentional, and supported controls differ by campaign.
Why it matters: Report observed brand demand separately from acquisition and confirm intended query coverage before changing exclusions. Mixed credit alone does not quantify lost money.
| Status | Criteria |
|---|---|
| PASS | Supported controls and observed query coverage match the documented acquisition role |
| FAIL | Verified query coverage conflicts with the documented role; unknown coverage stays Not checked |
8. Attribution Window Set
Threshold: Supported conversion window deliberately selected for the actual purchase cycle and measurement purpose; no universal seven-day minimum.
How to check: Go to Google Ads > Goals > Conversions > your purchase action > Settings. Check the click-through conversion window. Compare the current window with the purchase-cycle and lag evidence; a one-day window can be an intentional measurement choice.
Why it matters: A 1-day click window on a product with a 5-day consideration period means you miss conversions that you actually drove. The algorithm gets incomplete feedback. It stops bidding on keywords and audiences that actually work because it never sees the delayed conversions they produce.
| Status | Criteria |
|---|---|
| PASS | Supported window fits the documented sales cycle and measurement purpose |
| FAIL | Verified window mismatch; unreviewed defaults remain Not checked |
9. Feed Title Length
Threshold: Accurate identifying product facts, with useful distinctions early and no padding; 70-character coverage is an editorial preference.
How to check: Export your product feed. Check the character count of the title field for each product. Calculate what percentage have 70+ characters.
Why it matters: Accurate identifying detail can clarify product matching. Compare actual facts and query coverage; shorter titles can be appropriate, and length alone predicts neither additional matches nor impressions at the same bid.
| Status | Criteria |
|---|---|
| PASS | Reviewed titles contain accurate identifying facts and useful distinctions without padding |
| FAIL | Verified missing or misleading identifying information; title length alone is not a failure |
Part 1 Score
| Result | Count |
|---|---|
| PASS | ___/9 |
| FAIL | ___ |
Worksheet target: all applicable prerequisite checks reviewed, with critical gaps resolved or explicitly handled.
Prioritize verified critical gaps. An unreviewed or inapplicable list/feed check does not demonstrate waste or automatically block unrelated activity.
Part 2: Scaling Readiness Score
Score each element 0-10, where 0 = completely missing and 10 = airtight. Be honest. Generous scoring here only hurts you later.
Element 1: Conversion Tracking Accuracy
| Score | What It Looks Like |
|---|---|
| 0-3 | No conversion tracking, or values wildly off from actual revenue |
| 4-6 | Tracking works but values off by 10-20%, or intermittent gaps |
| 7-9 | Matched-event values within this rubric’s 5% target under documented definitions |
| 10 | Single-fire verified, matched-event values within this rubric’s 2% target, applicable enhanced data flow verified |
Your score: ___/10
Element 2: Conversion Action Hygiene
| Score | What It Looks Like |
|---|---|
| 0-3 | Verified duplicate purchase credit or unintended micro-events used for bidding |
| 4-6 | One purchase action but attribution window never reviewed |
| 7-9 | One purchase action, correct counting, window set intentionally |
| 10 | Intended outcomes, deduplication, counting, supported attribution model and window verified |
Your score: ___/10
Element 3: Merchant Center Quality
| Score | What It Looks Like |
|---|---|
| 0-3 | Multiple critical disapprovals, store quality unreviewed |
| 4-6 | No critical disapprovals but warnings present, store quality average |
| 7-9 | Clean diagnostics, most store quality recommendations addressed |
| 10 | All recommendations addressed, zero disapprovals, reviews enabled, shipping competitive |
Your score: ___/10
Element 4: Customer List Freshness
| Score | What It Looks Like |
|---|---|
| 0-3 | Verified fault in applicable list permission, eligibility or intended use; N/A excluded |
| 4-6 | Applicable list has known freshness or eligibility gaps; upload count alone is not serving eligibility |
| 7-9 | Purchaser list and high-value list uploaded, refreshed monthly |
| 10 | Relevant permitted lists have verified active-user eligibility, documented freshness and appropriate campaign use |
Your score: ___/10
Element 5: Campaign Segmentation
| Score | What It Looks Like |
|---|---|
| 0-3 | Everything in one or two campaigns, branded and prospecting mixed |
| 4-6 | Some separation but brand leakage into prospecting |
| 7-9 | Four pockets separated with minor overlap |
| 10 | Four pockets cleanly separated (branded search, prospecting search, branded shopping, prospecting shopping), zero brand leakage |
Your score: ___/10
Element 6: Negative Keyword Coverage
| Score | What It Looks Like |
|---|---|
| 0-3 | Verified irrelevant demand is untreated or valid demand is wrongly excluded |
| 4-6 | Intended exclusions are partly implemented with known scope gaps |
| 7-9 | Supported exclusions and observed query coverage fit the intended role, with minor gaps |
| 10 | Intended query coverage and supported controls verified; exclusions reviewed without mandatory additions or universal brand blocking |
Your score: ___/10
Element 7: Feed Attribute Completeness
| Score | What It Looks Like |
|---|---|
| 0-3 | Minimal attributes, many recommended fields empty |
| 4-6 | Required fields populated but optional fields sparse |
| 7-9 | Most recommended fields populated, GTINs present where available |
| 10 | 99%+ recommended fields populated, GTINs present, product highlights filled, custom labels structured |
Your score: ___/10
Element 8: Landing Page Quality
| Score | What It Looks Like |
|---|---|
| 0-3 | Slow load times (5+ seconds), poor mobile experience |
| 4-6 | Acceptable speed but cluttered purchase path |
| 7-9 | Fast on mobile, clear purchase path, good reviews visible |
| 10 | Sub-3s load time, mobile-optimized, clear purchase path, social proof visible, no friction in checkout |
Your score: ___/10
Element 9: Historical Conversion Volume
| Score | What It Looks Like |
|---|---|
| 0-3 | Fewer than 10 conversions/month |
| 4-6 | 10-29 conversions/month in this workload rubric; review actual uncertainty and lag |
| 7-9 | 30-50 conversions/month in this workload rubric; sufficiency depends on the decision |
| 10 | 50+ conversions/month across campaigns, consistent daily volume |
Your score: ___/10
Element 10: Reporting Clarity
| Score | What It Looks Like |
|---|---|
| 0-3 | Cannot separate branded from prospecting performance |
| 4-6 | Can separate but requires manual work each time |
| 7-9 | Clear reporting setup, branded vs prospecting visible in under 2 minutes |
| 10 | Pull branded vs prospecting performance in under 60 seconds, contribution margin tracked, dashboards built |
Your score: ___/10
Part 2: Calculate Your Total
| Element | Your Score |
|---|---|
| 1. Conversion tracking accuracy | ___/10 |
| 2. Conversion action hygiene | ___/10 |
| 3. Merchant Center quality | ___/10 |
| 4. Customer list freshness | ___/10 |
| 5. Campaign segmentation | ___/10 |
| 6. Negative keyword coverage | ___/10 |
| 7. Feed attribute completeness | ___/10 |
| 8. Landing page quality | ___/10 |
| 9. Historical conversion volume | ___/10 |
| 10. Reporting clarity | ___/10 |
| Total | ___/100 |
Score Interpretation
80-100: Ready to Scale
Most criteria meet this rubric; this does not establish profitable scaling. Move to building your scaling structure: feed optimization, search architecture, bidding progression, and pre-sell pages.
Your priority: Review economics, lag and risk before authorizing a measured budget test.
60-79: Fix the Gaps First
You have a workable foundation with holes. Identify every element scoring below 6 and address it before adding budget.
Your priority: Spend 1-2 weeks closing the gaps. A score does not quantify savings or the cost of delay.
Below 60: Do Not Scale Yet
Review the underlying findings before a budget increase; a low rubric score alone does not prove financial waste.
Your priority: Focus entirely on foundation work until you hit 80+. This is not discouraging - it is protecting your budget. Measure the result of the selected fixes.
Action Planning
If Part 1 has any fails:
Those are your immediate priorities. Block time this week. Most foundation items take 1-4 hours to fix. Do them in this order:
- Conversion tracking accuracy (everything depends on this)
- Conversion-action mapping and duplicate-event review
- Applicable enhanced-conversion data flow and diagnostics
- Campaign separation + brand negatives (cleans your data)
- Merchant Center, customer lists, attribution, feed titles
If Part 1 is all passes but Part 2 is below 80:
Investigate low-scoring applicable elements and prioritize verified severity, expected business impact and dependencies. A lower rubric score alone does not establish the largest financial drag.
If both parts look good:
Review margin, demand, attribution and lag before authorizing a scaling test. Potential architecture work includes: the four-pocket structure, bidding progression, budget deployment sequence, and advanced plays like competitor campaigns and Demand Gen.
What This Audit Does Not Cover
This audit organizes foundation review; the score does not validate every prerequisite or establish readiness to scale. It does not cover:
- Campaign architecture: How to structure branded search, prospecting search, branded shopping, and prospecting shopping for maximum clarity and control
- Bidding progression: When to use manual CPC, target ROAS, and maximize conversion value at each scaling stage
- Advanced plays: Competitor campaigns, Demand Gen for cold traffic, multi-market expansion, YouTube integration
- Operating system: Monthly review cadence, revenue-tier playbooks, performance dashboards
For the complete team-operated workflow, review the Google Ads AI Agentic System. The product page lists the current deliverables, price, license terms and setup responsibilities.
Use observed foundation gaps to choose the next implementation and evaluation plan.
Choose who handles the next step.
Use the reference yourself, book a focused paid working session, or have Tegra handle the ongoing channel work.
Search, Shopping, Performance Max and Demand Gen campaigns, plus the research, product feeds, static and video creative, and landing, offer and pre-sale pages behind them.
Explore managed Google Ads → · See paid working sessions →