Inside this resource.
7 sectionsA map of the published document. Choose a section to start reading.
- 01Put this guide to work
- 02What's Inside
- 03Scoring Summary
- 04Priority Fix Sequence
- 05The 3 Biggest Patterns We Find
View 2 more sections
Jump to a section
Put this guide to work
Review keyword/query intent, ad groups, RSA quality, negatives and destination fit; create a prioritized corrective brief.
Your task: Audit one Search campaign. Record the source, date range and reviewer beside the result. Leave anything you have not checked marked Not checked.
Related work: Map buyer searches before you build campaigns. · Score an RSA headline against clear copy criteria.
This is a house planning rubric, not Google eligibility guidance or a performance forecast. Counts, architecture choices and score bands are review preferences to adapt to goals, margins and lag. For each checked applicable row use 0=absent, 1=early work, 2=partial, 3=documented with gaps, 4=mostly verified, 5=verified against the stated applicable criterion. Mark unknowns Not checked and exclude N/A from earned/possible points; withhold fixed/210 bands for partial coverage.
What's Inside
Section 1: Campaign Structure Audit (8 Checkpoints)
| # | Checkpoint | Pass | Fail | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Brand/non-brand roles reviewed | Intent, reporting and budget roles documented; deliberate blending can be valid | Verified unintended mixing or misleading reporting | /5 |
| 2 | Ad groups organized by intent theme (not product catalog) | Single-theme ad groups with intent-matched RSAs | Multi-theme ad groups with 15-30+ mixed keywords | /5 |
| 3 | Match-type strategy reviewed | Selected match types and structure fit intent, measurement and bidding | Verified unnecessary fragmentation or irrelevant query coverage | /5 |
| 4 | Competitor terms isolated from generic campaigns | Dedicated competitor campaign or excluded from generic | Competitor terms mixed with category keywords | /5 |
| 5 | Campaign count fits available evidence | Distinct funded roles, volume and lag support the structure | Verified sparse/redundant structure impairs review or delivery | /5 |
| 6 | Ad group structure fits intent and evidence | Coherent themes with enough evidence for the intended review | Verified mixed intent or unnecessary fragmentation | /5 |
| 7 | Naming convention consistent and filterable | Format: Network_MatchType_Theme_Targeting | Inconsistent names, unclear structure | /5 |
| 8 | Applicable network controls reviewed | Current Search network options selected deliberately | Verified unintended network coverage | /5 |
Section Score: ___/40
Scoring Guide:
- 32-40: Structure is solid. Focus on optimization.
- 20-31: Review the lowest-rated structural checks and their affected scope.
- Below 20: Investigate material observed issues; a rubric score alone does not justify a rebuild.
Section 2: Quality Score Diagnostics (7 Checkpoints)
| # | Checkpoint | Pass | Fail | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9 | Keyword-level QS diagnostics available where applicable | Relevant component statuses inspected; no aggregate QS KPI | Applicable reported diagnostic issues left unreviewed | /5 |
| 10 | Low reported QS investigated in context | Observed keyword/component issues reviewed with query and page evidence | Verified relevance/experience defect remains unresolved | /5 |
| 11 | Expected CTR component reviewed | Applicable reported statuses inspected against actual query/ad fit | Verified issue remains untreated; missing QS is Not checked | /5 |
| 12 | Ad Relevance component reviewed | Applicable statuses assessed against query intent and ad content | Verified intent/ad mismatch remains unresolved | /5 |
| 13 | Landing Page Experience reviewed | Applicable statuses assessed alongside actual destination behavior | Verified destination defect remains unresolved | /5 |
| 14 | QS triage prioritized by impression volume (not alphabetical) | High-impression POOR keywords identified and prioritized | No QS monitoring process | /5 |
| 15 | QS components reviewed as diagnostics | Observed relevance/experience issues documented with evidence | No applicable diagnostic review | /5 |
Section Score: ___/35
Section 3: RSA Quality Audit (7 Checkpoints)
| # | Checkpoint | Pass | Fail | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 16 | RSA test plan fits available evidence | Distinct supported ad hypotheses with a review plan; three is optional | Verified missing, ineligible or incoherent ad coverage | /5 |
| 17 | Useful RSA asset coverage | Supported distinct assets within current limits; fifteen is optional | Verified missing required assets or repetitive/misleading copy | /5 |
| 18 | Headlines pass the 3-Rule Filter (visualizable, falsifiable, unique) | Majority pass all three tests | Generic headlines ("Premium Quality," "Shop Now") | /5 |
| 19 | RSA hypotheses distinguish buying questions | Purposeful differences wherever multiple ads are tested | Duplicated hypotheses prevent the intended comparison | /5 |
| 20 | Pinning reviewed against required messaging | Required terms pinned appropriately; remaining flexibility deliberate | Required disclosure may be omitted or pinning defeats the intended design | /5 |
| 21 | Cross-RSA repetition reviewed | Shared facts retained where useful; each test has a clear hypothesis | Redundant copy undermines the stated test; no universal similarity cutoff | /5 |
| 22 | Headline type diversity (keyword_match, hook, differentiator, question, CTA) | 3+ types per RSA | Only keyword-match or generic CTA headlines | /5 |
Section Score: ___/35
Section 4: Negative Keyword Audit (7 Checkpoints)
| # | Checkpoint | Pass | Fail | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 23 | Negative-keyword scope is evidence based | Applicable irrelevant demand handled without blocking valuable queries | Verified irrelevant demand or harmful exclusions unresolved | /5 |
| 24 | Shared exclusion candidates reviewed | Business-specific exclusions applied only to suitable inventory/roles | Verified list-scope or business-fit defect | /5 |
| 25 | Competitor-query role reviewed | Competitor coverage or exclusions selected from business fit and evidence | Verified unintended competitor traffic or harmful exclusion | /5 |
| 26 | Brand-query role and controls reviewed | Chosen brand controls match actual roles and preserve intended coverage | Verified unintended routing or harmful brand exclusion | /5 |
| 27 | Cross-campaign coverage reviewed | Shared queries assessed against roles and evidence | Unreviewed coverage; overlap alone is not waste | /5 |
| 28 | Destination matches transactional intent | Educational and offer pages cover intended queries; exclusions deliberate | Verified query/destination mismatch remains untreated | /5 |
| 29 | Search-term review cadence documented | Current risk/volume-appropriate review; no additions needed without evidence | Agreed review overdue or material query issue unresolved | /5 |
Section Score: ___/35
Section 5: Keyword Coverage Audit (7 Checkpoints)
| # | Checkpoint | Pass | Fail | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30 | Relevant query coverage documented | Dated research maps actual intent/demand gaps | No evidence-backed query map | /5 |
| 31 | Applicable intent hypotheses reviewed | Relevant evidence-backed layers included; inapplicable layers excluded | Documented valuable intent gap remains unreviewed | /5 |
| 32 | Intent mix fits the business decision | Funded query roles and economics support the chosen mix | Verified misallocation; no universal BOFU share | /5 |
| 33 | Competitor research assessed for business fit | Relevant competitor terms considered with demand, policy and economics | Applicable research gap unresolved; not every competitor term merits targeting | /5 |
| 34 | Specific query needs reviewed | Relevant specific terms assessed; word count does not prove lower competition | Verified relevant query gap remains untreated | /5 |
| 35 | Useful commercial modifiers reviewed | Only relevant, natural modifiers considered; counts are not coverage proof | Verified commercial-intent gap remains untreated | /5 |
| 36 | Keyword scoring applied (volume, relevance, difficulty, CPC) | Objective inclusion/exclusion criteria | No scoring methodology | /5 |
Section Score: ___/35
Section 6: Bidding & Budget Audit (6 Checkpoints)
| # | Checkpoint | Pass | Fail | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 37 | Bidding strategy fits supported type and goals | Accurate values, strategy eligibility and evaluation lag reviewed | Verified goal/strategy mismatch | /5 |
| 38 | Budget fits the proposed test and risk | Account economics, expected volume, lag and loss limit documented | Verified funding/risk mismatch; no universal 3x-CPA daily minimum | /5 |
| 39 | Brand funding reviewed against value | Coverage, incrementality and economics inform brand budget | Verified brand allocation issue; 100% share is not a prerequisite | /5 |
| 40 | Allocation follows commercial evidence | Marginal contribution, customer value, risk and strategic roles reviewed | Verified mismatch between allocation and business objective | /5 |
| 41 | Staged deployment with objective advancement criteria | Documented stage gates based on conversion data | All keywords/campaigns launched simultaneously | /5 |
| 42 | Optimization cadence fits risk and volume | Documented reviews cover material pacing, query, ad and tracking issues | Agreed review missing or material issue untreated | /5 |
Section Score: ___/30
Scoring Summary
| Section | Score | Max | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Campaign Structure | 40 | ||
| 2. Quality Score | 35 | ||
| 3. RSA Quality | 35 | ||
| 4. Negative Keywords | 35 | ||
| 5. Keyword Coverage | 35 | ||
| 6. Bidding & Budget | 30 | ||
| Total | 210 |
Overall Interpretation:
- 170-210: Well-structured account. Optimize within the current framework.
- 120-169: Several checked criteria need review; locate the actual issues before proposing changes.
- 80-119: Many checked criteria need investigation; the score does not establish account-wide damage.
- Below 80: Review material verified risks first; do not prescribe a full rebuild from the total alone.
Priority Fix Sequence
After scoring, fix in this order:
- Campaign structure (Section 1) - foundation for everything else
- Negative keywords (Section 4) - investigate irrelevant demand and harmful exclusions
- Quality Score (Section 2) - investigate keyword-level relevance/experience diagnostics
- RSA quality (Section 3) - CTR and conversion improvement
- Keyword coverage (Section 5) - addressable market expansion
- Bidding & budget (Section 6) - efficiency optimization
Prioritize verified critical issues and business impact; this sequence establishes no universal fastest ROI.
The 3 Biggest Patterns We Find
These are qualitative review patterns, not a measured prevalence claim:
Pattern 2: 47 campaigns, zero negative keywords. Campaign count is a vanity metric. Campaign count alone does not establish data starvation or harm. Review volume, roles, goals and lag before consolidating; a missing negative list alone is not proof of waste.
Pattern 3: Every RSA says the same thing. "Shop [Brand]. Free Shipping. Quality Products." Google has nothing to test. Three RSAs per ad group, each with 15 unique headlines across distinct emotional angles. That is one editorial testing plan, not a provider minimum.
How to Use This Template
- Pull your Google Ads data for the last 90 days
- Work through each checkpoint (30 minutes total)
- Score honestly - this is a diagnostic, not a performance review
- Identify the 3-5 lowest-scoring checkpoints
- Fix in the priority sequence above
- Re-audit in 30 days to measure improvement
Continue with the full system
This audit identifies the problems. The Google Ads AI Agentic System (see the current product page for price and license terms) gives you the complete rebuild methodology: the 21-query keyword research protocol for relevant intent hypotheses; actual usable terms depend on the market and evidence, the RSA scoring pipeline with 100-point rubric and 3-Rule Filter, the competitive intelligence system that finds Blue Ocean positioning angles, and the staged deployment framework with objective advancement gates.
Check the current native product page for module and delivery scope. The reported $21K-to-$336K case is a retrospective account observation, not a forecast or proof that this rubric caused the outcome.
Choose who handles the next step.
Use the reference yourself, book a focused paid working session, or have Tegra handle the ongoing channel work.
Search, Shopping, Performance Max and Demand Gen campaigns, plus the research, product feeds, static and video creative, and landing, offer and pre-sale pages behind them.
Explore managed Google Ads → · See paid working sessions →