Inside this resource.
7 sectionsA map of the published document. Choose a section to start reading.
- 01Put this guide to work
- 02The Rubric
- 03The Scoring Sheet
- 04Worked Examples: Full Scoring
- 05Cross-RSA Validation
View 2 more sections
Score the writing, not its predicted return.
The six criteria allocate 100 editorial rubric points. They organize review; they do not predict CTR, approval, ROAS or the score of your account.
| Criterion | Maximum available points | Review question |
|---|---|---|
3-Rule Filter | 30 | Does the headline pass the guide's core wording filter? |
Keyword relevance | 20 | Does the wording fit the supplied search intent? |
Clarity | 15 | Can the reader understand the message? |
Proofability | 15 | Can the actual product evidence support the claim? |
Uniqueness | 10 | Does the headline add a distinct useful message? |
CTR potential | 10 | What is the editorial reason to test it, without predicting a click rate? |
Read the full source: The Rubric · The Scoring Sheet · What This Rubric Doesn't Cover
Jump to a section
Put this guide to work
Review specificity, proof, differentiation and headline-set coverage; prioritize revisions before account publishing.
Your task: Score one RSA headline set. Record the source, date range and reviewer beside the result. Leave anything you have not checked marked Not checked.
How to interpret it: This score describes copy craft and headline-set coverage. It does not predict ROAS. Every numeric or comparative ad claim still needs product-specific support.
Related work: Review the creative before you buy attention. · Search Campaign Audit Template
This is a house editorial rubric, not a Google requirement, validated CTR model or launch approval. Use only product-supported claims and actual offer terms. Mark unknown evidence Not checked; do not treat a claim as verified because it is specific. Withhold a full/100 result until applicable criteria are rated. Three-RSA/45-headline coverage below is an optional testing plan.
The Rubric
Criteria 1: The 3-Rule Filter (30 points)
All product, review, guarantee and savings examples below are hypothetical. A score is conditional on real substantiation; a specific number or duration is not evidence of uniqueness or truth.
This is binary. All three rules pass, or you score zero. No partial credit.
Rule 1 - Visualizable: Can the reader picture the benefit?
Pass: "Monday to Friday, One Charge" (you picture a work week without plugging in) Pass: "From Dull to Gleaming in 30 Min" (you picture the before/after) Fail: "Premium Sound Awaits" (what does "premium sound" look like?) Fail: "Quality Products Available" (no mental image created)
Rule 2 - Falsifiable: Is there a verifiable claim?
Pass: "10,000+ Cars Protected" (can be checked) Pass: "Rated 4.9/5 by 2,800 Detailers" (verifiable number) Fail: "Trusted by Many" (how many? Can't verify) Fail: "Best Quality Available" (subjective, can't disprove)
Rule 3 - Unique: Could a competitor use this headline word-for-word?
Pass: "5-Layer Ceramic with SiO2" (specific to your formula) Pass: "$49 Replaces $600/Year Waxing" (specific to your price point) Fail: "Free Shipping on All Orders" (any store could say this) Fail: "Premium Skincare Products" (every skincare brand could claim this)
Scoring: All 3 pass = 30 points. Any one fails = 0 points. This is intentionally harsh. A headline that fails the filter needs perfect scores on all remaining criteria to reach 70/100 - which almost never happens.
Criteria 2: Keyword Relevance (20 points)
Does the headline contain theme words from the keyword cluster? Does it match the search intent?
| Score | Description |
|---|---|
| 18-20 | Contains primary cluster keyword or close variant. Directly addresses search intent. |
| 14-17 | Contains related theme words. Intent alignment is clear but indirect. |
| 10-13 | Loosely connected to cluster theme. Reader has to make the connection. |
| 5-9 | Tangentially related. Could fit multiple clusters. |
| 0-4 | No connection to cluster keywords or intent. Wrong ad group. |
Example: Cluster theme is "ceramic car coating protection"
- "2-Year Ceramic Protection" = 18/20 (contains "ceramic" and "protection," directly addresses intent)
- "Your Paint, Fully Shielded" = 14/20 (related concept, clear connection, but no cluster keywords)
- "Made for Car Enthusiasts" = 8/20 (loosely related, doesn't address protection intent)
Criteria 3: Clarity (15 points)
Can the reader understand this headline in under 2 seconds? At 30 characters maximum, every word must carry weight.
| Score | Description |
|---|---|
| 13-15 | Instant understanding. No jargon. No ambiguity. A 12-year-old gets it. |
| 10-12 | Clear to the target audience. Might use industry terms the buyer knows. |
| 7-9 | Requires a moment of thought. Slightly clever or abstract. |
| 4-6 | Confusing. Wordplay that doesn't land. Multiple possible interpretations. |
| 0-3 | Incomprehensible or misleading. Reader doesn't know what you're selling. |
Example:
- "One Coat. Two Years. Done." = 15/15 (instant, no ambiguity)
- "SiO2-Infused Nano Formula" = 10/15 (clear to car enthusiasts, jargon for everyone else)
- "Protection Meets Innovation" = 5/15 (what does this mean? Protection from what? What innovation?)
Criteria 4: Proofability (15 points)
Is this claim backed by data, evidence, or information on your landing page?
| Score | Description |
|---|---|
| 13-15 | Claim is directly verifiable on the landing page (review count, warranty terms, test results). |
| 10-12 | Claim is supported but not directly stated (implied by product specs or description). |
| 7-9 | Claim is reasonable but no landing page evidence supports it. |
| 4-6 | Claim is a stretch. Landing page would need updates to support it. |
| 0-3 | Claim is fabricated or cannot be verified anywhere. |
Example:
- "Rated 4.9/5 by 2,800 Reviews" = 15/15 (review score visible on page)
- "Lasts 2 Years Guaranteed" = 14/15 (warranty terms stated in product description)
- "Used by Top Detailers" = 7/15 (probably true but no proof on the page)
- "Best Coating on Earth" = 2/15 (unverifiable superlative)
Why this matters: Headlines that promise things the landing page doesn't deliver tank conversion rates. The click got them there. The disconnect pushes them away. Google also factors landing page relevance into Quality Score.
Criteria 5: Uniqueness (10 points)
Does this headline only work for YOUR product and YOUR landing page?
| Score | Description |
|---|---|
| 9-10 | Could only be used by your brand. Contains specific claims, numbers, or features unique to you. |
| 7-8 | Mostly unique. One or two competitors might also claim this. |
| 4-6 | Generic within your category. Most competitors in your space could use it. |
| 1-3 | Completely generic. Works for any e-commerce brand in any category. |
Example:
- "$49 Replaces $600/Year Waxing" = 10/10 (specific price, specific comparison, only works at this price point)
- "Lab-Tested 9H Hardness" = 9/10 (specific test result, few competitors can claim)
- "Professional-Grade Formula" = 4/10 (every coating brand says this)
- "Shop Now - Free Shipping" = 1/10 (literally any e-commerce store)
Criteria 6: CTR Potential (10 points)
Would someone stop scrolling and click? Does this headline create an emotional response - curiosity, relief, urgency, surprise?
| Score | Description |
|---|---|
| 9-10 | Scroll-stopper. Creates immediate curiosity or desire. "I need to know more." |
| 7-8 | Strong pull. Addresses a clear pain point or desire. Likely to earn the click. |
| 5-6 | Decent. Communicates value but doesn't create urgency or curiosity. |
| 3-4 | Flat. Factual but no emotional hook. Reader moves past it. |
| 0-2 | Invisible. Blends into every other ad on the page. |
Example:
- "Still Waxing Every Month?" = 9/10 (hits a pain point, question format proposes a recognizable concern; engagement remains to be measured)
- "Skip the $500 Detailer Bill" = 8/10 (specific savings, addresses real frustration)
- "2-Year Ceramic Protection" = 6/10 (solid claim but doesn't provoke an emotional response)
- "Ceramic Coating Available" = 2/10 (states a fact nobody cares about)
The Scoring Sheet
Use this template for every headline candidate. Score all 25 candidates before selecting your top 15.
Headline: [Your headline here]
Character count: [Must be 30 or fewer]
1. 3-Rule Filter: __/30 (0 or 30 only)
Visualizable? Y / N
Falsifiable? Y / N
Unique? Y / N
2. Keyword Relevance: __/20
3. Clarity: __/15
4. Proofability: __/15
5. Uniqueness: __/10
6. CTR Potential: __/10
TOTAL: __/100
Decision: KEEP (70+) / CUT (below 70)
Worked Examples: Full Scoring
Example 1: Strong Headline
Headline: "One Coat. Two Years. Done." Character count: 26/30
| Criteria | Score | Reasoning |
|---|---|---|
| 3-Rule Filter | Not checked /30 | Visualizable and testable; duration alone does not establish uniqueness. Verify actual evidence and competitor fit. |
| Keyword Relevance | 16/20 | Implies durability and coating. Doesn't contain exact cluster keyword but intent is clear. |
| Clarity | 15/15 | Instant understanding. Three fragments, zero ambiguity. |
| Proofability | Not checked /15 | Requires the actual product page, applicable warranty conditions and evidence supporting the performance wording. |
| Uniqueness | Not checked /10 | Compare the actual competitive set; two-year wording is not inherently exclusive. |
| CTR Potential | 8/10 | Creates a contrast between effort (one coat) and result (two years). The "Done." finisher adds decisiveness. |
| Total | Withheld | Verify unknown evidence before completing the score. |
Example 2: Borderline Headline
Headline: "Your Paint Deserves Better" Character count: 26/30
| Criteria | Score | Reasoning |
|---|---|---|
| 3-Rule Filter | 0/30 | Visualizable: barely (what does "better" look like?). Falsifiable: no ("better" is subjective). Unique: no (any paint protection product). Failed - zero. |
| Keyword Relevance | 12/20 | References "paint" but doesn't address protection or coating. |
| Clarity | 13/15 | Clear message, just vague. |
| Proofability | 5/15 | What claim is being made? Nothing to verify. |
| Uniqueness | 3/10 | Any car care brand could use this. |
| CTR Potential | 6/10 | Creates mild emotional response but nothing specific. |
| Total | 39/100 | CUT |
A filter failure leaves at most 70/100, requiring perfect remaining scores to reach the stated KEEP threshold.
Example 3: Surprising Reject
Headline: "Free Shipping + Money-Back" Character count: 26/30
| Criteria | Score | Reasoning |
|---|---|---|
| 3-Rule Filter | 0/30 | Visualizable: no (what's the mental image of free shipping?). Falsifiable: yes (policy is verifiable). Unique: no (thousands of stores offer this). Failed on 2 of 3 - zero. |
| Keyword Relevance | 4/20 | No connection to any product-specific cluster. |
| Clarity | 15/15 | Crystal clear. |
| Proofability | Not checked /15 | Verify actual shipping exclusions and money-back conditions before using either claim. |
| Uniqueness | 1/10 | Literally any e-commerce store. |
| CTR Potential | 5/10 | Nice-to-know but not a reason to click YOUR ad. |
| Total | Withheld | Low relevance/uniqueness in this example; evidence remains unchecked. |
This is the most common "but it's a good headline!" objection we hear. Shipping or return terms may address a real buyer objection and belong in a headline when useful and substantiated. This rubric's creative preference does not make them unsuitable for every account.
Cross-RSA Validation
After scoring individual headlines, validate across your 3 RSAs.
Within One RSA (15 headlines)
- All 15 must be unique - no trivial rewrites of the same claim
- Must include at least 3 of these 5 types: keyword match, hook, differentiator, question, CTA
- No two headlines should feel like the same message in different words
Across 3 RSAs (45 headlines per cluster)
- All 45 must be unique. Zero duplication between RSAs.
- Each RSA should emphasize a different buying motivation (authority, transformation, value)
- The same claim can appear in different RSAs only if expressed through genuinely different framing
The test: Read all 15 headlines from RSA 1 out loud. Then read all 15 from RSA 2. Do they feel like ads for different audiences? If yes, your differentiation works. If they feel like the same ad rewritten three times, start over.
Quick Reference: The Threshold System
| Total Score | Decision | Action |
|---|---|---|
| 90-100 | Strong candidate | Verify claims, context and approval before assignment |
| 80-89 | Keep | Solid candidate, include in top 15 |
| 70-79 | Conditional keep | Include only if needed to fill 15 |
| 60-69 | Rework | Has potential but needs revision on weak criteria |
| Below 60 | Cut | Don't force it. Generate a new candidate. |
What This Rubric Doesn't Cover
This rubric scores individual headlines. It tells you whether a headline earns its spot in your RSA.
What it doesn't cover:
- The angle-based clustering system (how to organize campaigns around buying motivations, not keywords)
- The RSA personality architecture (how to differentiate 3 RSAs within a cluster so each tells a genuinely different story)
- The keyword scoring formula (which keywords deserve budget and which are hidden waste)
- The full iteration system (when to kill underperformers, how to replace them, what to test next)
- Description writing and scoring at 90 characters
- Negative keyword architecture across 5 tiers
For the complete team-operated workflow, review the Google Ads AI Agentic System. The product page lists the current deliverables, price, license terms and setup responsibilities.
This rubric is the quality gate. The Agentic System is the machine that feeds it.
Choose who handles the next step.
Use the reference yourself, book a focused paid working session, or have Tegra handle the ongoing channel work.
Search, Shopping, Performance Max and Demand Gen campaigns, plus the research, product feeds, static and video creative, and landing, offer and pre-sale pages behind them.
Explore managed Google Ads → · See paid working sessions →