The working sequence.
13 sectionsFollow the document’s sequence, or jump to the step you need.
- 01Principle 1: Specificity
- 02Principle 2: Visceral Language
- 03Principle 3: Tension/Relief
- 04Principle 4: Loss Framing
- 05Principle 5: Borrowed Authority
View 3 more sections
Jump to a section
Put this guide to work
Evaluate a Demand Gen asset against eight copy/creative principles, identify failed checks and brief the next revision.
Your task: Review one creative. Record the source, date range and reviewer beside the result. Leave anything you have not checked marked Not checked.
Related work: RSA Headline Scoring Rubric · Awareness-Level Copy Templates
How to Use This Checklist
This is an editorial rubric, not a validated conversion predictor or platform requirement. Use only claims, endorsements, review counts and before/after examples supported for the actual product and approved use. Health and financial claims need particular review.
- Print one copy per creative set (or one per image if scoring individually)
- Review each principle and mark PASS or FAIL
- Note specific fixes for any FAIL
- Minimum passing score: 6/8 per image
- Any image with 3+ failures gets reworked before production
Principle 1: Specificity
The rule: Every text overlay must contain at least one specific element - a number, a timeframe, a measurable outcome, or a named problem.
Why it matters: Specific language makes a promise easier to inspect and visualize. Use only substantiated numbers; compare actual response rather than assuming every specific claim outperforms a broad one.
Pass/Fail test: Does the copy contain a specific number, timeframe, or measurable claim?
| Check | Result |
|---|---|
| Contains a specific number? | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
| Contains a timeframe? | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
| Contains a measurable outcome? | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
| Contains a named problem? | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
PASS requirement: At least ONE "Yes" above.
Examples of passing copy:
- "28-day energy protocol" (number + timeframe)
- "Reduce redness in 72 hours" (measurable outcome + timeframe)
- "Cuts cleaning time to 4 minutes" (specific number)
- "Sold out 3x in 2024" (number + timeframe)
Examples of failing copy:
- "Boost your energy" (no specifics)
- "Calming formula" (no measurement)
- "Easy cleaning" (no number, no timeframe)
- "Best-selling" (compared to what?)
Score: [ ] PASS [ ] FAIL
Fix notes: _______________
Principle 2: Visceral Language
The rule: Try concrete sensory language when it accurately describes the product or customer experience.
Why it matters: Sensory words can make the message easier to picture. Review clarity with your audience rather than inferring a neurological effect.
Pass/Fail test: Read the copy out loud. Can you physically feel anything?
| Check | Result |
|---|---|
| Contains temperature words? (burning, freezing, crisp, warm) | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
| Contains texture words? (gritty, silky, rough, smooth) | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
| Contains movement words? (crashing, pulling, sinking, racing) | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
| Contains pain/relief words? (throbbing, stinging, melting, releasing) | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
| Reader can physically feel the copy? | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
PASS requirement: At least ONE sensory word category present AND the "physically feel" test passes.
Examples of passing copy:
- "Your feet are screaming by 3pm" (pain - reader feels this)
- "That 2am acid-burn feeling" (temperature + pain)
- "Silk against sunburned skin" (texture + temperature contrast)
Examples of failing copy:
- "Comfortable shoe insoles" (abstract, no sensation)
- "Soothing skincare solution" (generic, activates nothing)
- "High-quality material" (no sensory engagement)
Score: [ ] PASS [ ] FAIL
Fix notes: _______________
Principle 3: Tension/Relief
The rule: Present a relevant problem and a credible path to relief. Treat the tension/relief pattern as a copy hypothesis to test.
Why it matters: A clear problem can explain why the proposed solution matters; it does not force a click.
Pass/Fail test: Does the creative (individual image or sequence) create a problem and offer resolution?
| Check | Result |
|---|---|
| Problem/tension clearly stated? | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
| Resolution/relief implied or shown? | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
| The tension is specific to the target audience? | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
PASS requirement: Tension AND relief both present. Tension must be specific (not generic).
Tension/Relief patterns:
- Problem/Solution: "Breakouts every Monday morning?" then "Clear by Friday. Every week."
- Before/After implication: "Remember when your jeans fit?" then "They will again."
- Fear/Security: "Your mattress is 8 years old." then "Tonight could be different."
For 20-image sequences:
- Images 1-5: Pure tension (name the problem)
- Images 6-10: Tension with a hint of relief
- Images 11-15: Relief building through proof
- Images 16-20: Full relief through transformation
Score: [ ] PASS [ ] FAIL
Fix notes: _______________
Principle 4: Loss Framing
The rule: Test a truthful loss frame against a gain frame where the customer evidence supports it. The 30% sequence check below is a suggested creative mix, not a scientific threshold.
Why it matters: Framing changes the message. Quantified losses require actual evidence; compare response rather than assuming one frame wins.
Pass/Fail test: Is the primary message framed as a loss rather than a gain?
| Check | Result |
|---|---|
| Frames around what reader is losing/missing/wasting? | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
| Paired with resolution path (not pure negativity)? | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
| At least 30% of sequence uses loss framing? | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
PASS requirement: Loss framing present AND paired with resolution.
Loss framing formulas:
- "You're paying $X for Y that doesn't work"
- "Every morning you skip this, you lose Z"
- "Your competitors figured this out 6 months ago"
- "[Time period] of [result] you'll never get back"
Critical: A loss frame can leave the reader with an unresolved problem. Pair it with a truthful, clear path forward and test the response.
Score: [ ] PASS [ ] FAIL
Fix notes: _______________
Principle 5: Borrowed Authority
The rule: Include at least one authority element in every creative set. When your brand lacks recognition, borrow credibility from entities your audience already trusts.
Why it matters: Relevant third-party evidence can give an unfamiliar brand a credible reason to be considered. Verify the source, count, permission and relevance of reviews or endorsements; trust and conversion effects still need measurement.
Pass/Fail test: Is there at least one authority element in the creative set?
| Authority Type | Present? | Specific Element |
|---|---|---|
| Social proof (review count, customers served) | [ ] Yes [ ] No | _______________ |
| Expert endorsement (doctor, professional, specialist) | [ ] Yes [ ] No | _______________ |
| Media authority (publications, press mentions) | [ ] Yes [ ] No | _______________ |
| Institutional (certifications, awards, badges) | [ ] Yes [ ] No | _______________ |
| Volume proof (units sold, years in business) | [ ] Yes [ ] No | _______________ |
PASS requirement: At least ONE authority element present with a specific claim (not vague).
Score: [ ] PASS [ ] FAIL
Fix notes: _______________
Principle 6: Proof Integration
The rule: Every claim needs a proof element within 2 visual beats. Claims without proof are noise. Proof without claims is confusing. The combination is persuasion.
Why it matters: Make a bold statement without supporting it immediately, and skepticism fills the gap. The brain seeks validation automatically.
Pass/Fail test: Is every benefit claim backed by proof within the same image or next image?
| Check | Result |
|---|---|
| Benefit claim has matching proof element? | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
| Proof appears within 2 visual beats of the claim? | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
| Proof type appropriate for claim type? | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
PASS requirement: All claims backed by proof within 2 visual beats.
Proof types to consider (choose by claim and evidence; this is not a validated ranking):
- Transformation proof: Before/after with specific metrics and context; a comparison alone does not isolate causality
- Volume proof: "12,000 customers" with visual representation
- Process proof: How it's made/tested (quality perception)
- Comparison proof: Side-by-side against alternatives
- Time proof: "Results in X days" with dated evidence
Pairing guide:
- Performance claims get before/after proof
- Speed claims get timestamp proof
- Quality claims get ingredient/material proof
Score: [ ] PASS [ ] FAIL
Fix notes: _______________
Principle 7: One Clear Action
The rule: Every image drives exactly one action. Not two. Not "visit our site or follow us." One thing.
Why it matters: A clear primary action helps the reader understand the next step. Treat fewer competing choices as a design hypothesis and measure its effect rather than promising a conversion increase.
Pass/Fail test: Can you describe the desired action in one phrase?
| Check | Result |
|---|---|
| Single CTA per image? | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
| CTA consistent across 20-image set? | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
| No competing actions? | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
| CTA matches audience temperature? | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
PASS requirement: One clear action, consistent across the set, matching audience temperature.
CTA hierarchy by audience temperature:
- "Shop Now" - warm/hot audiences (direct purchase)
- "See How It Works" - cold audiences (curiosity)
- "Get [Specific Offer]" - all temperatures (value)
- "Try Risk-Free" - cold/warm audiences (objection reduction)
Score: [ ] PASS [ ] FAIL
Fix notes: _______________
Principle 8: Continuation
The rule: Give a useful reason to continue to the destination. Treat curiosity as a creative hypothesis; show material terms and enough information to make an informed choice.
Why it matters: Enough information to be compelling, but withholding the resolution. The gap between what you show and what they need to know drives the click.
Pass/Fail test: Does the creative leave an intentional gap that only clicking can fill?
| Check | Result |
|---|---|
| Information gap present? | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
| Enough context to be compelling? | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
| Resolution requires clicking through? | [ ] Yes [ ] No |
PASS requirement: Intentional gap present with enough context to make closing the loop feel worthwhile.
Continuation techniques:
- Numbered reveals: "3 reasons your skin breaks out (Reason 3 changes everything)"
- Partial transformation: Show the before and the process, but the full "after" requires clicking
- Social curiosity: "12,000 women switched to this after seeing the results" - what results?
- Incomplete benefit: Present the mechanism but not the full outcome
Score: [ ] PASS [ ] FAIL
Fix notes: _______________
Score Summary
| Principle | Score |
|---|---|
| 1. Specificity | [ ] PASS [ ] FAIL |
| 2. Visceral Language | [ ] PASS [ ] FAIL |
| 3. Tension/Relief | [ ] PASS [ ] FAIL |
| 4. Loss Framing | [ ] PASS [ ] FAIL |
| 5. Borrowed Authority | [ ] PASS [ ] FAIL |
| 6. Proof Integration | [ ] PASS [ ] FAIL |
| 7. One Clear Action | [ ] PASS [ ] FAIL |
| 8. Continuation | [ ] PASS [ ] FAIL |
Total PASS: ____ / 8
Minimum to proceed: 6/8 Target: 8/8
If your creative scores below 6/8, rework the failing principles before spending budget. Three or more failures on a single image means the concept needs rethinking, not just copy tweaks.
Quick-Reference: Cooper Framework Validation
Run this after the 8 principles pass. Every image must also satisfy these 5 structural requirements:
- Total text blocks on image: 3-4 maximum (headline + supporting text + CTA = 3 is ideal)
- ONE dominant element owns 40-50% of visual weight
- Visual message matches copy message (congruency type: Literal / Emotional / Symbolic)
- ONE core message per image (7-word test: describe the message in 7 words or fewer)
- Readable at 200px wide, high contrast, center-weighted, 72px+ margins from edges
Cooper score: ____ / 5
Any Cooper failure = automatic rework regardless of DR principle score.
What Comes Next
This checklist scores your creative against the 8 principles. It tells you what's failing and gives you the framework to fix it.
For the complete team-operated workflow, review the Meta Ads AI Agentic System. The product page lists the current deliverables, price, license terms and setup responsibilities.
Use the checklist to brief revisions and review generated creative before testing; the system supports the workflow, and its output still needs evidence and editorial review.
Choose who handles the next step.
Use the reference yourself, book a focused paid working session, or have Tegra handle the ongoing channel work.
Ongoing media buying, customer research, creative strategy, copy, static and video production, campaign deployment and optimization.
Explore managed Meta Ads → · See paid working sessions →